About Nice Coins
Family owned and operated in Attica, New York. Your trusted partner for precious metals and collectibles in Western New York.
Built on Passion,
Driven by Integrity
Nice Coins & Collectibles LLC was founded with a simple mission: to provide the collectors and investors of Western New York with a trustworthy, knowledgeable, and fair place to buy and sell precious metals, coins, and collectibles.
Located in the heart of Attica, New York — a small town in Wyoming County with a big community spirit — we've built our reputation on honest dealings, expert knowledge, and a genuine passion for the items that pass through our doors.
From gold and silver bullion to rare numismatic coins, from Magic: The Gathering cards to Pokémon collectibles, we serve a diverse community of hobbyists, collectors, and investors. Every customer who walks through our door receives the same level of respect, expertise, and fair pricing.
As a family-owned business, we understand that trust is earned. That's why we use transparent, market-based pricing, insure every transaction, and take the time to educate our customers about the items they're buying or selling.
Family Owned & Operated
We're not a franchise or a faceless corporation. We're your neighbors in Attica, NY, and we treat every customer like family.
Insured Transactions
Every transaction at Nice Coins is fully insured. Your items are protected from the moment you walk in until the deal is done.
Fair Market Pricing
We use live spot prices and transparent margins. No hidden fees, no bait-and-switch. What you see is what you get.
Expert Knowledge
Our team brings years of experience in numismatics, precious metals, and trading card games. We know what your items are truly worth.
Proudly Serving Western New York
Rooted in Attica, reaching across the region
Attica, New York sits at the crossroads of Wyoming County, making us easily accessible from across Western New York. Whether you're coming from Buffalo, Batavia, Warsaw, or anywhere in between, Nice Coins is worth the drive.
We're proud to be part of the Attica community and the broader Western New York region. Our customers come from across Wyoming County, Genesee County, Erie County, and beyond — drawn by our reputation for fair dealing and expert service.
Can't make it to our store? We also serve customers through our insured mailer program, allowing you to safely ship your items for evaluation and purchase from anywhere in the United States.
Our Location
Nice Coins & Collectibles LLC
18 Market St, Attica, NY 14011
Wyoming County, Western New York
Serving customers from:
Family owned and operated in Attica, NY
Insured transactions — your items are protected
Fair market pricing — always
Serving Western New York collectors since 2020
Come Visit Us in Attica
We'd love to meet you. Stop by our store for a free appraisal, browse our inventory, or just chat about coins and collectibles.