Coins & Collectibles
From rare numismatic treasures to the hottest trading card games — we buy, sell, and trade it all at fair market prices in Attica, New York.
Collectible Coins
Whether you're a seasoned numismatist or just starting your collection, Nice Coins offers a curated selection of rare and collectible coins. From Morgan Silver Dollars and Walking Liberty Half Dollars to modern proof sets and commemorative issues, our inventory spans centuries of American coinage history.
We also buy coin collections of all sizes. Inherited a collection? Downsizing? We provide free, no-obligation appraisals and pay fair market value for every piece.
Free Coin Appraisals
Bring your coins to our Attica, NY location for a free, no-obligation evaluation by our experienced team.
Schedule a VisitSell Your MTG Collection
We buy singles, sealed product, and entire collections. Get competitive offers based on current market values.
Get a QuoteMagic: The Gathering
Nice Coins is your Western New York destination for Magic: The Gathering. We carry a wide selection of singles from all sets, sealed booster boxes, and accessories. Whether you're building a competitive deck or hunting for that elusive mythic rare, we've got you covered.
Looking to sell? We buy MTG cards at competitive prices based on current TCGPlayer market values. From bulk commons to Reserved List staples, we're interested in it all.
Pokémon Cards
The Pokémon TCG market continues to thrive, and Nice Coins is your go-to source in the Attica, NY area. We carry modern and vintage Pokémon cards, sealed product, and graded cards from PSA and CGC.
Have a collection to sell? Whether it's a binder of Base Set holos or a stack of modern chase cards, we offer top dollar for Pokémon cards and collections. We also buy graded cards at competitive prices.
Sell Your Pokémon Cards
Top dollar paid for vintage and modern Pokémon cards. Bring your collection in for a free evaluation.
Get a QuoteReady to Buy or Sell?
Visit our store in Attica, NY or give us a call. We're always happy to discuss your collection and provide fair, honest evaluations.